Texas Surprise Billing Arbitration: SB 1264 and Federal IDR
Texas out-of-network providers have two arbitration remedies for underpaid claims: the federal No Surprises Act IDR process and the Texas state system created by SB 1264 (administered by the Texas Department of Insurance), which covers state-regulated plans including many HMO and ERS arrangements. Texas is the most active IDR state in the country: over 524,000 federal disputes originated in Texas in the second half of 2025 alone. CMS data has shown provider win rates of 89% to 91% in Texas, Florida, Arizona, and Virginia. Larry Moskowitz is licensed in Texas and represents Texas providers on contingency.
Why Texas providers have the strongest IDR position in the country
Texas sits at the center of the IDR economy by every measure. Federal data for the second half of 2025 shows 524,630 disputes initiated in Texas; no other state reached six figures. The state's own system under SB 1264 predates and parallels the federal one: the Texas Department of Insurance received over 1 million arbitration and mediation portal requests from 2020 to 2023 (820,485 deemed eligible), with volumes growing from ~49,000 requests in 2020 to over 519,000 in 2023. And the outcomes favor providers: CMS state-level data showed providers winning 89% to 91% of resolved cases in Texas, Florida, Arizona, and Virginia, the highest rates in the nation.
For a Texas emergency group, anesthesia practice, freestanding ER, or ASC, the practical conclusion is that underpaid claims here aren't a cost of doing business; they're recoverable revenue sitting in a system that statistically favors you. The constraint is the same as everywhere: deadlines.
Federal IDR vs. Texas SB 1264: which applies?
Plan type decides the track. Self-funded ERISA plans and most coverage regulated federally go through federal IDR; Texas state-regulated plans (including many fully-insured, HMO, and state employee arrangements) go through the TDI system, which provides mediation for facilities and arbitration for providers with its own deadlines and fee structure. Texas freestanding emergency centers (over 200 of them, more than half the national total) are nearly all out-of-network by design and are among the heaviest users of the state system.
| Federal IDR | Texas SB 1264 (TDI) | |
|---|---|---|
| Plan types | Self-funded ERISA, most group/individual | Texas state-regulated plans, many HMO/ERS |
| Providers | All OON providers/facilities/air ambulance | Texas providers; facilities via mediation track |
| Decision style | Baseball-style arbitration | Arbitration (providers) / mediation (facilities) |
| Administrator | CMS-certified IDR entities | Texas Department of Insurance |
We determine the correct track for every claim in the eligibility review; filing in the wrong forum wastes the filing window.
What about unpaid awards and aged Texas claims?
Same answer as federally, with Texas teeth: arbitration awards are binding, and when an insurer doesn't pay, enforcement is a legal matter: complaints to TDI or the federal Departments, and litigation where warranted. For claims that aged past both arbitration windows, we evaluate litigation-based recovery separately; Texas providers have pursued underpayment recoveries on aged A/R through the courts with meaningful success.
Frequently asked questions
I'm a freestanding ER in Texas: which system do I use?
Both, depending on the patient's plan. FECs are nearly always out-of-network, making every commercially-insured visit a potential dispute. We sort state vs. federal per EOB in the review.
Does SB 1264 still matter now that the federal NSA exists?
Yes: it covers the plan types the federal act doesn't reach, and TDI's data shows the state system remains heavily used. Many Texas claims are state-track; many are federal. The answer is claim-specific.
Are you actually licensed in Texas?
Yes: Larry Moskowitz is licensed in both Florida and Texas, and has spent 30+ years on provider-side insurance recovery. That dual licensure is deliberate: the two states lead the nation in IDR volume.
What does it cost?
Nothing upfront; pure contingency from new money recovered; nothing owed if we don't recover. Details in the engagement letter before any filing.
Find Out What Your Claims Are Actually Owed
Free, confidential, no-obligation review. Send us a recent EOB (or a month of them) and we'll tell you straight: which claims qualify, which forum, what they may be worth, and how much time you have left to file. No fee unless we recover.