The IDR Report Card: Federal Arbitration Data, Quarterly

Every quarter, CMS publishes Federal IDR public use files showing how many disputes were filed, who filed them, who won, and how much arbitrators awarded. This page tracks the numbers that matter to providers: the win rate (about 85% in 2025), the median award versus the insurer's qualifying payment amount (about 445% in 2025), volume by state (Texas dominates), and awards by specialty (surgical claims command the largest multiples). All figures come from CMS Federal IDR reports; links appear with each table.

The headline numbers (latest reporting period)

MetricH2 2025 (Q3 and Q4)Trend
Disputes initiated nationally1,372,563↑ vs. 1,186,812 in H1 2025
Provider win rate (determinations)~85%Stable (88% peak Q2 2025)
Median prevailing award vs. QPA~445%Stable
Top state by volumeTexas: 524,630 initiatedNo other state above 100K
Median award, emergency services~334% of QPANo trend data
Median award, surgical specialties~1,503% of QPAHighest-multiple categories
Median time to determination25 days (Q4)Improving
Federal admin fee$115 per party per disputeAfter TMA IV vacated the 600% fee hike

Source: CMS Federal IDR supplemental tables and public use files; analysis by Georgetown CHIR. Update this table every CMS release; the freshness is the point.

What the numbers mean for your practice

Three takeaways recur quarter after quarter. First, the system works for providers who use it: an ~85% win rate with median awards over four times the insurer's benchmark is not a loophole; it's the process functioning as designed. Second, volume concentration is extreme: three organizations (Radiology Partners, HaloMD, TeamHealth) account for roughly three-quarters of resolved dispute lines, which means the overwhelming majority of eligible independent providers still aren't filing. Third, geography matters: Texas and Florida consistently lead in both volume and win rates, which is why this practice is licensed in exactly those two states.

Ready to see where your claims stand? Review your options in our Federal IDR arbitration, Florida §408.7057, or Texas SB 1264 guides, or send an EOB for a free review.

Methodology and sources

All data from CMS Federal IDR public reports and public use files (published bi-monthly) and Georgetown University Center on Health Insurance Reforms analyses. Win rates reflect payment determinations, not initiated disputes. "Median award vs. QPA" compares the prevailing provider offer to the qualifying payment amount, not to billed charges. Figures are updated within two weeks of each CMS release; the dateModified stamp reflects the latest refresh.

Find Out What Your Claims Are Actually Owed

Free, confidential, no-obligation review. Send us a recent EOB (or a month of them) and we'll tell you straight: which claims qualify, which forum, what they may be worth, and how much time you have left to file. No fee unless we recover.