Federal IDR Arbitration Under the No Surprises Act
Federal Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) is a binding arbitration process created by the No Surprises Act that lets out-of-network healthcare providers challenge underpaid insurance claims before a certified, neutral arbitrator. Both sides submit one payment offer; the arbitrator picks one. CMS data from 2025 shows providers win approximately 85% of determinations, with a median prevailing award of about 445% of the insurer's qualifying payment amount. Results vary by provider type, claim volume, and documentation.
What is federal IDR arbitration?
The No Surprises Act, which took effect in 2022, protects patients from surprise out-of-network bills and gives providers a federal remedy when insurers underpay. If a health plan's initial payment on a qualifying out-of-network claim is too low, the provider can open negotiation, and if that fails, escalate to IDR: a "baseball-style" arbitration in which each side submits a single offer and a CMS-certified IDR entity selects one, with no splitting the difference.
The process applies to emergency services, non-emergency out-of-network services at in-network facilities, and air ambulance services, for patients covered by most group health plans (including self-insured ERISA plans), ACA marketplace plans, and FEHB benefits. Medicare, Medicaid, VA, TRICARE, and Indian Health Service claims follow separate processes and are not eligible for federal IDR.
How long do I have to file an IDR dispute after an EOB?
The federal clock is short, and it starts on the EOB date (not the date you notice the underpayment):
| Step | Deadline |
|---|---|
| Open negotiation with the insurer | 30 business days from the EOB |
| Initiate IDR after failed negotiation | 4 business days from the end of open negotiation |
| Submit offers and supporting documentation | 10 business days after IDR initiation (per IDR entity scheduling) |
Miss the window and the underpayment is generally permanent: the insurer keeps the difference. This is the single most common way providers lose money they were legally owed: not in arbitration, but by letting the deadline pass. If your EOBs are more than a few weeks old, treat review as urgent. (Florida providers: the state remedy under §408.7057 offers a separate 12-month window for many claims; see our Florida IDR page.)
How often do providers win, and how much?
According to CMS Federal IDR reporting for 2025, providers prevailed in approximately 85% of payment determinations. When providers prevailed, the median award was approximately 445% of the qualifying payment amount (QPA), the insurer's median contracted rate for the service, which is the federal benchmark arbitrators anchor to. Emergency services account for roughly half of all determinations, and awards vary by specialty: in the second half of 2025, CMS data showed median awards around 334% of QPA for emergency services and far higher multiples for surgical and neurology claims.
What does federal IDR cost a provider?
Handled through our firm: nothing upfront. Representation is pure contingency: our fee comes only from new money we recover, never from amounts the insurer already paid, and if we recover nothing you owe us nothing. The federal administrative fee for IDR is currently $115 per party per dispute, plus the IDR entity's arbitrator fee; we advance process costs as part of representation and reconcile them against recovery. Your engagement letter spells all of this out before anything is filed.
Can claims be batched in federal IDR?
Yes, batching is how high-volume providers make IDR economical. Federal rules allow multiple qualified claims to be resolved in one arbitration when they involve the same provider (or group), the same insurer, the same or similar service codes, and the same 30-business-day negotiation window. Following the TMA IV court decision, overly restrictive batching limits were vacated, expanding what can be batched. Batching strategy (which claims to group, which to file singly) is one of the places attorney judgment materially affects outcomes.
What happens if the insurer refuses to pay the award?
IDR determinations are binding, and plans are required to pay within 30 days of the determination. Non-payment is a growing, documented problem across the industry, and it is exactly where a law firm differs from a filing platform: we enforce. Remedies include complaints to the Departments (HHS/Labor/Treasury tri-agency enforcement) and, where appropriate, litigation to compel payment of the award. Platforms that process claims cannot take an insurer to court; we can.
Which providers qualify for federal IDR?
Any out-of-network provider, facility, or air ambulance operator treating patients with qualifying coverage, most commonly:
- Emergency medicine groups (the single largest IDR category, about half of all determinations)
- Anesthesiology, radiology, pathology, and other hospital-based specialties
- Ambulatory surgery centers and other facilities
- Air ambulance and qualifying ground/EMS transport
- Any specialist providing non-emergency out-of-network care at an in-network facility
Not sure whether a specific claim qualifies? That's what the free review is for: send the EOB and we give you a straight answer.
Why an attorney instead of an IDR filing platform?
Volume platforms process claims; they don't represent providers. The differences that matter at decision time:
| Filing platform | Larry Moskowitz, P.A. | |
|---|---|---|
| Offer strategy | Algorithmic | Attorney judgment on every offer |
| Unpaid awards | Cannot litigate | Enforcement through agencies and courts |
| Florida §408.7057 & Texas SB 1264 | Generally federal-only | All three remedies evaluated per claim |
| Aged claims beyond IDR windows | Out of scope | Assessed for litigation-based recovery |
| Who signs their work | A dashboard | A licensed attorney (FL & TX, 30+ years in provider-side insurance recovery) |
Frequently asked questions
Does IDR apply to in-network claims?
No: IDR is specifically the out-of-network remedy under the No Surprises Act. In-network underpayments are contract disputes handled differently (and we evaluate those separately).
Will filing IDR damage my relationship with insurers?
IDR is a statutory right created by federal law, used at massive scale: CMS received millions of disputes in 2025. Exercising a legal remedy through the federal process is a normal business practice, not a provocation.
How long does arbitration take?
CMS data shows median time to determination measured in weeks (25 days in Q4 2025 reporting), though backlog varies by IDR entity.
Can you handle claims outside Florida and Texas?
Yes: federal IDR is a federal process administered nationwide by CMS-certified entities, and we represent providers in it across the country. State remedies are limited to Florida (and Texas plan types we evaluate case-by-case).
What do you need to review my claims?
A recent EOB showing the underpayment, the underlying billing detail (CPT/HCPCS codes, service dates), and any insurer correspondence. Redact patient identifiers as appropriate for the initial review.
Find Out What Your Claims Are Actually Owed
Free, confidential, no-obligation review. Send us a recent EOB (or a month of them) and we'll tell you straight: which claims qualify, which forum, what they may be worth, and how much time you have left to file. No fee unless we recover.